What is the Psychology Behind Testimonials?

3 min to read

Testimonials use several psychological principles that play a crucial role in the behavior of consumers. They are effective because they leverage our natural predisposition to rely on other people’s experiences.

This further “social proof” helps when making decisions, especially if the customer hasn’t made the choice. Think of it as a way to gain a new perspective on your situation from someone relevant to you.

Pro Tip:
Include testimonials by people who are as close as possible to your target audience. This approach can impact the effectiveness of social proof.
Key Takeaways:
  • Testimonials act as validation, which may affect customers’ decisions and increase the chances of them making a purchase
  • Ensure the showcased testimonials are truthful and updated
  • Use testimonials combined with other effective techniques
Hocoos small logo Answers Customer Testimonials

What psychological principles make testimonials effective?

Key psychological principles include:

  • Social proof: People observe the actions of others to form opinions. Testimonials provide such guidance.

  • Authority: Endorsements made by trusted experts and celebrities carry weight.

  • Liking: We tend to be influenced more by individuals who are relatable to us and have characteristics that we like.

  • Scarcity: Testimonials that mention the limited availability of an article can create a sense of urgency among customers.
Pro Tip: 
Use a combination of principles for increased efficiency. As an example, well-regarded experts can be used to create video testimonials that integrate both authority and liking.

Do different types of testimonials work better in different situations?

Yes. Different types of testimonials appeal to distinct customers, and purchase motivations. To illustrate, look at these types of testimonials:

  • Video testimonials are associated with emotional appeal, which can influence the audience’s decision-making.

  • Written testimonials are adaptable and have a broader reach when shared across different platforms.

  • Quantitative testimonials like “9 out of 10 dentists recommend…” may appeal to the audience’s logical side.

  • User-generated content on social media platforms tends to be viewed as more authentic and relatable by younger demographics.
Pro Tip: 
Vary the types of testimonials to find which suits your target audience and offerings the most. A/B testing provides a potential strategy for gathering such insights.

What are some common mistakes businesses make when using testimonials?

Although reviews are highly valuable, there are potential challenges to consider when using them. These include:

  • Using only overly positive testimonials: While positive testimonials are important, an overreliance on too favorable ones can raise questions about their genuineness.

  • Failing to engage a range of voices: Inclusive representation of customers may appeal to more audiences.

  • Burying testimonials on your website: Make the collected testimonials visible on your homepage and product pages.

How do testimonials fit into the broader context of marketing psychology?

Using testimonials in marketing psychology has played a significant role in influencing consumer behavior. While testimonials can influence customer decisions, their impact is often amplified when presented alongside other forms of evidence and social proof.

Examples:

  • Pairing customer reviews with a limited-time offer adds a sense of urgency and scarcity, and motivates taking action. 

  • Testimonials with the free trial offer appeal to the ‘reciprocity’ principle and make people want to try the product.

Can testimonials backfire? If so, how?

Yes. While testimonials can have positive impacts, they can also be associated with negative outcomes if not used responsibly. Here is how:

  • Fake testimonials: Fabricated endorsements can negatively impact your reputation while using genuine testimonials builds credibility and strengthens your connection with your audience.

  • Irrelevant testimonials: Ensure that the reviews and endorsement videos are persuasive by focusing on the interests of your target audience.

  • Outdated testimonials: Ensure that customers have accurate information by showcasing testimonials that reflect the relevancy of your current offerings.

When utilizing testimonials, make sure that it’s authentic, relevant, and transparent.

Pro Tip: 
It’s advisable to assess your testimonials and ensure their validity regularly. Outdated or inappropriate content should be reviewed and, if necessary, removed.

Conclusion

Testimonials are a form of social proof that impacts the perceived value of your product or service. Once you grasp the psychology behind testimonials – how they utilize social proof, authority, and liking, among others – you can use them appropriately to establish trust with your audience and angles. Remember to remain genuine and use other techniques as aids to testimonials for maximum effectiveness.

Table of Contents

READY TO KICK-START YOUR SMALL BUSINESS JOURNEY?

Important Consideration: The information provided by our expert team is designed to give you a general understanding of the website creation process and the features available to you. It's important to note that this information is not a substitute for professional advice tailored to your specific needs and goals.
Read our editorial standards for Answers content.
Our goal is to empower you to create an amazing website. If you have questions or need guidance during the building process, don’t hesitate to Contact us. We're happy to provide assistance and point you in the right direction.